Man charged with attempted homicide remains free as lack of competency confirmed

Remaining Ad Time Ad - 00:00

MADISON (WKOW) – A Sun Prairie man charged with attempted first degree intentional homicide in the stabbings of two people remains free after a judge Friday declined to change a ruling on his mental health status.

“I do not find new information upon which another competency evaluation should be done,”  Dane County Judge Ellen Berz says.

Earlier this year, prosecutors joined Campa Gomez’s attorney in stipulating that Campa Gomez was not competent to stand trial.  They relied on a psychologist’s opinion after Campa Gomez was evaluated over a period of days.

But in June, a proposed emergency detention of Campa Gomez was dismissed after a psychiatrist found Campa Gomez to have no significant mental illness.

“He looked at that time like he did not have a major mental illness that would warrant a mental health commitment,”  Dr. Philip Lomas testified Friday.

But Lomas also testified if he had been privy to the reports of the psychologist and two others who had also examined Campa Gomez previously and agreed he was not competent to stand trial, he would have done additional testing on Campa Gomez to determine if the potentially unsupervised release into the community would have been appropriate.

“I am shocked that he was not given all of these reports,”  Berz says.

“He didn’t request them at the time,”  Assistant Dane County District Attorney Galen Stroebe tells 27 News.

Berz has ordered Campa Gomez have no contact with the victims, and barred him from a portion of Sun Prairie.

Victim Letty Melchor’s sister, Lydia Valdez tells 27 News the restraining order fails to reassure Melchor.  “She’s in fear,”  Valdez says.

“It’s not just what happened to my sister, it’s what can happen to anybody else that’s out there now,”  Valdez tells 27 News.

Prosecutors say Campa Gomez stabbed Melchor and a man in September 2016 after a brief argument.

Judge finds no grounds to reopen question of Campa Gomez’s competency #WKOW

Dan Plutchak

Dan Plutchak

Social Media and Digital Content Manager, 27 News

Top Stories

Showers through early afternoon, windy

Showers through early afternoon, windy

MADISON (WKOW) — You can expect a blustery SW wind today ahead of an approaching cold front, one that is

Connect With 27 News
More News

BREAKING: Madison Mayor Paul Soglin says he will seek re-election

MADISON (WKOW) — 27 News has confirmed Madison Mayor Paul Soglin will seek another term. Soglin announced the run early

Hand-inserted microchips try to help those living with dementia

Three Square Market developed the microchips so workers could scan into the building or buy things in the breakroom. It

Community gets first look at new MPD Midtown police station

The Midtown community had the chance to see their new police station for the first time at an open house.

Janesville family shares story dealing with rare disease

More cases of a rare disease that's similar to polio are popping up across the nation. We're seeing it here in

Madison man makes TIME’s Health Care 50 list

A Madison man has made TIME magazine's list of the top people transforming health care in America. 

Scroll to top
Skip to content